Buenos Aires Times

argentina ARA SAN JUAN

Defence Ministry: We lack technology to explore raising ARA San Juan

Oscar Aguad says country lacks 'modern technology' capable of 'verifying the seabed' to extract the ARA San Juan, which was discovered yesterday, almost exactly a year after it mysteriously disappeared.

Saturday 17 November, 2018
Defence Minister Oscar Aguad talks during a press conference in Buenos Aires. The Navy announced early Saturday that they have located the missing submarine ARA San Juan in the Atlantic, a year after it disappeared with 44 crew-members aboard.
Defence Minister Oscar Aguad talks during a press conference in Buenos Aires. The Navy announced early Saturday that they have located the missing submarine ARA San Juan in the Atlantic, a year after it disappeared with 44 crew-members aboard. Foto:AP/Pablo Stefanec

More Argentina News

Hours after announcing the dramatic discovery of the ARA San Juan, the submarine that was lost deep in the Atlantic a year ago with 44 crew-members aboard, the government said Saturday that it is unable to recover the vessel at the present time, drawing anger from missing sailors' relatives who demanded that it be raised.

Defence Minister Oscar Aguad said at a press conference that the country lacks "modern technology" capable of "verifying the seabed" to extract the ARA San Juan, which was found 907 metres (2,975 feet) deep in waters off Peninsula Valdes, roughly 600 kilometres (373 miles) from the port city of Comodoro Rivadavia.

Earlier in the morning, the Navy said a "positive identification" had been made by a remote-operated submersible from the US company Ocean Infinity. The company, commissioned by the Argentine government, began searching for the missing vessel September 7.

Experts say raising the submarine would be an enormous undertaking costing a billion dollars or more. Aguad said Argentina had "no means" to do so.

Relatives of the dead sailors were seen hugging each other, holding their heads in despair and crying inconsolably.

It remained unclear what the next steps could be.

Admiral Jose Villan, the Navy's new top commander, said that the rough terrain on the ocean floor made it difficult for search vessels, which had already trawled the site, to find the submarine.

Pieces that were 11, 13 and 30 metres long were spotted in a "moon-like zone with craters and canyons," said Navy Captain Enrique Balbi, adding that the hull had been "crushed inwards."

Aguad met earlier with family members to show photos taken by an underwater robot. They showed a propeller, the sub's bow with torpedo-launching tubes, and an upper section of the vessel lying on the ocean floor.

"We are all destroyed here," said Yolanda Mendiola, the mother of crewman Leandro Cisneros, 28.

How to advance

In a statement,Ocean Infinity CEO Oliver Plunkett said authorities would have to determine how to advance.

"We would be pleased to assist with a recovery operation but at the moment are focused on completing imaging of the debris field," he said.

Navy commander Jose Luis Villan urged "prudence," saying that a federal judge was overseeing the investigation and would be the one to decide whether it was possible to recover a part or the entirety of the ship.

Without adequate technological capabilities, however, Argentina would likely need to seek assistance from foreign countries or pay Ocean Infinity or another company, potentially complicating its recent commitment to austerity.

Argentina is currently facing a currency crisis and double-digit inflation that has led the government to announce sweeping measures to balance the budget amid a US$57-billion line of credit from the International Monetary Fund (IMF).

Any move to recuperate the vessel would also be a logistically large and challenging undertaking based on the submarine's distance from the coast, its depth, and the kind of seabed upon which it is resting.

Relatives

Relatives of crew members were determined to fight for it to be quickly surfaced.

Isabel Vilca, the half sister of crewman Daniel Alejandro Polo, said that the discovery was just the beginning. She said families need to recover the remains of their loved ones to know what happened and help prevent similar tragedies.

"We do know they can get it out because Ocean Infinity told us they can, that they have equipment," said Luis Antonio Niz, father of crew member Luis Niz. "If they sent him off, I want them to bring him back to me."

The submarine's discovery was announced just two days after families of the missing sailors held a one-year commemoration for its disappearance on November 15, 2017. The San Juan was returning to its base in the coastal city of Mar del Plata when contact was lost.

On the anniversary Thursday, President Mauricio Macri said the families of the submariners should not feel alone and delivered an "absolute and non-negotiable commitment" to find "the truth."

On Saturday, Aguad said that the vessel was found to be in an area that investigators had deemed "most likely."

Debris

Officials showed images of the submarine, which was located on a seabed with its hull totally deformed. Parts of its propellers were buried and debris was scattered up to 70 metres (230 feet) away.

The German-built diesel-electric TR-1700 class submarine was commissioned in the mid-1980s and was most recently refitted between 2008 and 2014. During the US$12-million retrofitting, the vessel was cut in half and had its engines and batteries replaced. Experts said refits can be difficult because they involve integrating systems produced by different manufacturers, and even the tiniest mistake during the cutting phase can put the safety of the ship and crew at risk.

The Navy said previously the captain reported on November 15, 2017, that water entered the snorkel and caused one of the sub's batteries to short-circuit. The captain later communicated that it had been contained.

Some hours later, an explosion was detected near the time and place where the San Juan was last heard from. The Navy said the blast could have been caused by a "concentration of hydrogen" triggered by the battery problem reported by the captain.

Investigation

Macri promised a full investigation after the submarine was lost. Federal police raided naval bases and other buildings last January as part of the probe, soon after the government dismissed the head of the Navy.

The government gave up hope of finding survivors after an intense search aided by 18 countries, but a few Navy units have continued providing logistical support to Ocean Infinity.

On Saturday, Plunkett tweeted: "Our thoughts are with the many families affected by this terrible tragedy. We sincerely hope that locating the resting place of the ARA San Juan will be of some comfort to them at what must be a profoundly difficult time."

He also said: "This was an extremely challenging project and today's successful outcome, following the earlier search operations, firmly endorses our technology."

The company unsuccessfully searched for the Malaysia Airlines plane that disappeared in 2014 over the Indian Ocean.

The Seabed Constructor, equipped with cameras that can submerge 6,000 metres below the surface, was set to receive a US$7.5-million reward for finding the missing sub.

Lawyer Sonia Krescher questioned the timing of the sub's discovery, saying it was "weird" coming after the one-year anniversary of its loss.

"We are going to ask them to refloat it," she said. "We need to see the bodies and know what happened."

Added Cecila Kaufmann, who lost her husband Luis Leiva, "Now that they've found it, they need to give us back our loved ones."

Families of the missing crew still want answers, but Saturday at least brought the biggest one.

"What I feel," said Luis Tagliapietra, "is a mixture of immense sadness and the feeling of a battle won.

"We found them."

- TIMES/AP/AFP

Poll

Op-Ed

Top Stories

  1. 1Allegations spark Argentina’s own #MeToo momentAllegations spark Argentina’s own #MeToo moment
  2. 2Dec. 10th-16th: What We Learned This Week
  3. 3Prosecutors request arrest of Techint CEO Paolo Rocca
  4. 4‘Imagine the impact of being present during the kidnapping of your colleagues’
  5. 5#MiraComoNosPonemos: Argentines speak out against sexual abuse
  6. 6BP and Bridas: a renewed marriage of convenience
  7. 7Macri's OECD seduction to continue at G20 summit
  8. 8West hit by a triple whammy
  9. 9China goes back to its original world plan
  10. 10Editorial: Darthés, denunications and due process