Paraguay’s star status among investors shaken after bank scandal
Ueno Bank scandal and downfall of President Santiago Peña have left investors questioning whether Paraguay is still a good bet.
Paraguay won over investors in recent years thanks to strong growth, low taxes and a reputation as a safe haven in a volatile region. But the president’s downfall, a central bank in disarray and a financial firm in ruins have left investors questioning whether the country is still a good bet.
Police detained former President Santiago Peña – the nation’s jet-setting, English-speaking salesman – and his ex-central bank chief, Carlos Carvallo, earlier this month on corruption charges related to the collapse of Ueno Bank, which left more than 2.9 million clients without access to their money.
Fitch Ratings placed Paraguay on watch for a credit downgrade on Wednesday, citing the potential economic and fiscal fallout from Ueno’s collapse. Paraguay’s sovereign risk has jumped about 30 basis points since September to 134. Although still low by Latin America standards, it’s so far upended a long-term decline in risk perceived by investors.
Business owners on the ground applauded Congress’ lightning-fast approach, impeaching Peña just three days after regulators closed Ueno. Foreign investors are more hesitant to believe everything is patched up. The bank’s international bonds, which started November above 85 cents on the dollar, have nosedived to about five cents.
The Ueno scandal has effectively shut Paraguay’s corporate issuers out of global capital markets and will force the government to pay higher borrowing costs as investors demand a bigger risk premium, Alpha Credit Advisors partner Cesar Fernandez said.
“This situation has weakened the institutions,” Fernandez said in a telephone interview from London. “Now we need to be more careful when investing because we need to account for the political establishment as one of the factors in our investment process.”
Wedged between Argentina and Brazil, landlocked Paraguay is a relative newcomer to international capital markets, selling its first sovereign bond in 2013. Transparency International’s Corruption Perceptions Index has long ranked it near the bottom in South America.
Yet rapid growth, credible economic policy and alignment with US administrations burnished Paraguay’s reputation. It earned investment grade status from Moody’s Ratings in 2024, followed by S&P Global Ratings last December. The Inter-American Development Bank hosted its annual meeting in the nation’s capital, Asunción, earlier this year.
Even more recently, Washington was all-in on Paraguay. In October, Peña met US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent in Washington days after hosting Deputy Secretary of State Chris Landau in Asuncion. Carvallo chaired the International Monetary Fund’s meetings too.
To be sure, Paraguay’s economy continues to post strong growth, inflation is below two percent and foreign direct investment has steadily picked up for years. The fundamentals are just overshadowed by reputational damage.
The central bank’s credibility as a banking regulator also suffered as Carvallo, who had previously led Ueno’s predecessor company, dismissed concerns about the commercial lender’s operations before it failed. The monetary authority started repaying Ueno savers from the deposit insurance fund last week.
“It is imperative that the central bank restore its credibility and reputation, both domestically and internationally, as quickly as possible,” the central bank’s new chairman Jorge Schreiner told reporters late Tuesday.
It won’t be easy to rebuild confidence. Hungary’s largest lender, OTP Bank, had expressed excitement as recently as August after boosting its stake in Ueno to nearly 10 percent. Now it’s taking a US$32-million charge on that investment, which Deputy Chief Executive Officer Laszlo Bencsik called a “very bad and unpleasant” experience.
“We didn’t know about the problems and neither did the regulator,” Bencsik told reporters on Wednesday after the publication of the Hungarian bank’s earnings. “We only learned of it now and by then it was too late.”
Denim maker Jorge Bunchicoff never thought a major bank like Ueno would go under and take the president down with hit. Based in Paraguay, he received dozens of calls from nervous investors including Brazilians who were thinking about pausing their projects. He says some projects will still move forward.
“The institutions responded well. Everything unfolded in less than two weeks with a speed that I found remarkable,” said Bunchicoff, co-founder of Blue Design, whose factory near the capital Asunción exports premium jeans to the US, UK and Japan. “My view is that we exit this situation on a stronger footing.”
Ranching and farming, the lynchpins of Paraguay’s economy, should see little fallout from the Ueno scandal despite the damage it inflicted on the country’s reputation, said Uruguayan businessman Rodrigo Artagaveytia, whose agriculture services firm Everdem manages more than 42,000 cattle in Paraguay.
“The sector that could be most affected is forestry, which relies more heavily on large institutional investors. They are naturally going to look at Paraguay differently and pay closer attention” especially if the nation’s investment grade status is threatened, he said.
Uruguayan private equity fund IBF Negocios is pushing ahead with negotiations to acquire two Paraguayan companies for nearly US$20 million, co-founder Hugo Benedetti said. But further investments in Paraguay are off the table for now due to recent events, he said.
“This won’t come without a cost for Paraguay,” Benedetti said about Ueno. “I think the investment community will exact a price. People are going to be more cautious. We are going to be more cautious.”
related news
-
Miners negotiate cross-border tie-ups to unlock Argentina copper
-
Pope Leo wraps up South America homecoming tour
-
First Milei, now Lula enters the fray to shape Spain’s election
-
Elon Musk's Tesla sets date for long-awaited arrival in Argentina
-
Argentina beaten by Uruguay in first game since Messi's retirement
-
Soft power bounces back
-
China’s AI gamble
-
Does pope rhyme with hope?
-
Stories that caught our eye: November 6 to 13