70-year-old man jailed for life over murder of three lesbian women
Justo Fernando Barrientos convicted of murderous hate crime after setting fire to a room shared by four women in a Buenos Aires boarding house in May 2024; Pamela Cobbas, Mercedes Roxana Figueroa and Andrea Amarante died after killer set fire to the room they shared with Sofía Castro Riglos, who survived attack.
A court in Buenos Aires on Wednesday sentenced 70-year-old Justo Fernando Barrientos to life imprisonment for the murder of three lesbian women and the attempted murder of a fourth in a shocking hate crime two and a half years ago.
During the night of May 5 to 6, 2024, Barrientos threw an incendiary substance into a room where Pamela Cobbas, Mercedes Roxana Figueroa, Andrea Amarante and Sofía Castro Riglos were sleeping at a boarding house in the Barracas neighbourhood south of the capital.
Oral Criminal and Correctional Court No. 5 of Buenos Aires, comprising judges Adrián Pérez Lance, Juan Manuel Grangeat and Cinthia Oberlander, found Barrientos guilty of three murders and one attempted murder, aggravated by hatred of the victims' sexual orientation, extreme cruelty and the use of a means capable of endangering the public, said the Public Prosecutor's Office (MPF).
The court rejected the defence team's request for an acquittal on the grounds of insufficient evidence. Lawyers also sought to lower the conviction to ordinary homicide without aggravating circumstances.
In his closing arguments in October, prosecutor Juan Manuel Fernández Buzzi said: "The motive for the crime was hatred. This was not an ordinary homicide: he deliberately set them on fire, with the aim of burning them alive, making them suffer and die in agony."
"They were subjected to harassment and discrimination by Barrientos because they were lesbians and because they were women," he said.
According to the prosecution's reconstruction of events, when one of the women tried to escape as the fire spread, Barrientos struck her and pushed her back to prevent her from getting out.
Court testimonies describe how Barrientos blocked the room door and physically assaulted one of the women, repeatedly hitting and kicking her, as she tried to crawl out of the flames, before neighbours helped the victims reach the shared shower area to alleviate their burns.
Cobbas died on May 6, Figueroa two days later and Amarante on May 12, all from severe burns sustained in the attack.
Castro Riglos, 52, was the sole survivor. She suffered burns to three percent of her body and spent almost a month in hospital. She did not attend the trial.
The women had reportedly been subjected to systematic harassment by Barrientos, who referred to them using a derogatory slur for lesbians, the court heard.
Barrientos did not speak for much of the trial, though he addressed the court on Wednesday before hearing his sentence, saying: "Listen: I feel innocent, that's all I can tell you."
‘Important recognition’
Before the verdict, Luciana Sánchez, a lawyer representing Castro Riglos and Cobbas, criticised the investigation, saying the case’s original judge had been reluctant to gather evidence and recognise the attack as one motivated by the victims' sexual orientation and identity.
Sánchez welcomed the conviction as "a very important recognition," but said the ruling did not go far enough.
"The recognition of this as a hate crime motivated by the victims' sexual orientation is an important first step. The National Judiciary has an enormous debt to repay, and the sentence is not enough to satisfy us," she said.
The case sparked outrage across Argentina and prompted an impromptu vigil outside the boarding house where the attack took place.
Following the verdict, Amnesty International Argentina criticised the court for failing to apply the aggravating circumstance of gender-based violence, which it said had been experienced by the victims and highlighted by all the prosecution parties.
However, the NGO welcomed the ruling, saying it "sets a historic precedent in the judicial response to lesbicides," a term referring to the killing of a person because of their lesbian sexual orientation.
The court is due to publish the full reasoning behind its verdict on February 19, 2027.
– TIMES/AFP/NA
related news
-
Bullrich: ‘Suspension of PASO primaries is a done deal’
-
Milei’s reform to suspend primary elections overcomes key hurdle
-
Argentina one of seven nations not to back UN vote against gender violence
-
Peter Thiel's fund increases stake in Vaca Muerta oil producer Vista Energy
-
Milei says young voters will lead him to re-election
-
Up to 20 provinces to hold elections before October 2027 presidential vote
-
Government condemns Princess Anne’s visit to Malvinas
-
Nico Paz bags two as Argentina thrash Costa Rica 7-0
-
Trump's Latin America allies recalibrate after US election earthquake