Buenos Aires Times

sports San Lorenzo makes waves with banner

When football gets political

The demand for answers and the re-appearance of Santiago Maldonado extended all the way onto the pitch last weekend as the Superliga season kicked off.

Saturday 23 September, 2017
A banner demanding the re-appearance of Santiago Maldonado, who went missing over one month ago, is held up before San Lorenzo’s opening match of the Superliga season last weekend.
A banner demanding the re-appearance of Santiago Maldonado, who went missing over one month ago, is held up before San Lorenzo’s opening match of the Superliga season last weekend. Foto:Cedoc.

More Sports News

“Where is Santiago Maldonado?” The mystery surrounding the whereabouts of the young artisan has dominated Argentina since the start of August, with the Gendarmerie (Border Guards) facing allegations that the missing activist disappeared during a  protest involving Mapuche demonstrators in Chubut, in an episode that has raised serious questions over the actions of security  forces and the government. The clamour for a resolution to the grim case has spilled over into the sporting arena, in another  reminder that football and politics can often be intertwined.

On the opening weekend of the Superliga season, a San Lorenzo’s  fans group walked out prior to the club’s clash against Racing Club with a banner pleading for his reappearance. In a moment of tragicomic confusion the act appeared to be at first rejected by the AFA, only for a senior executive, Defensores del Belgrano  President Marcelo Achile, to overrule, blaming a misunderstanding with a more junior pencil-pusher. “I could never accept a  refusal to spread the demand for the live reappearance of Santiago Maldonado,” Achile emphasised, in a laudable gesture.

Similar scenes were witnessed in the build-up to Temperley- River Plate, with the home players voicing their own protest, while  Argentina goalkeeper Nahuel Guzmán chose the moment he returned to his home country to show a T-shirt asking simply,  “Where is Santiago?” The issue has transcended sport, but not everyone was pleased to see it raised.

Plenty of commenters  argued against the banners, on the grounds that politics should stay well away from stadiums. Assuming for a second that the  reappearance of a missing person — surely as uncontroversial a topic as any that one can imagine — is somehow laced with  political intent, it is a long-running tiresome debate. In Europe, authorities have leaned towards expelling political statements  from their glossy, hyper-commercialised and sponsor-friendly game, with sometimes ridiculous and arbitrary results.

On those grounds a team like Barcelona can be fined repeatedly by UEFA for their fans — not the club, but its unaffiliated and  independent supporters — flying the Estrellada flag, a symbol of Catalan nationalism, at the Camp Nou. Scottish club Celtic  were similarly sanctioned for the appearance of Palestinian flags in solidarity with that cause, while in perhaps the most  deplorable application of the rules, Polish side Legia Warsaw were punished for displaying a moving mural commemorating the  Warsaw Uprising, an ironic demonstration of the limits of free speech if ever there was.

But if those draconian norms rule in  Europe, they certainly do not apply locally. Football games are regular hosts of messages, be it for the recovery of the disputed  Malvinas Islands or the anti-domestic violence call of Ni Una Menos. Such shows of solidarity on the part of players and  directors do not seem to have awoken anything like the controversy that Maldonado has. Nor, for that matter, did Carlos  Tevez’s declaration to Animales Sueltos on the very same weekend that “Mauricio Macri is the man who can change this  country,” a comment tinged with the party political purpose absent in calls for the young artisan’s reappearance.

The truth is that  football, like all other professions, is a place where its employees and employers hold a vast array of different opinions. The  overwhelming majority decline to comment on most issues, preferring to stick to purely sporting matters in interviews and on  social media.

Some, like San Lorenzo President Matias Lammens, Guzmán and Tevez, speak eloquently and with feeling about  their beliefs, and with every right to do so. The former two in particular have long held an affinity with human rights groups such  as the Grandmothers of the Plaza de Mayo, supporting them in their struggle, while Tevez has helped make a real difference in impoverished neighbourhoods like Fuerte Apache where he grew up.

Football is ultimately a reflection of the society that  surrounds it, and it is pointless to pretend otherwise.

While in Europe the presence of ‘edgy’ messages is an affront to the  anodyne Brave New World the likes of UEFA and FIFA like to promote for their game, here the sport remains a forum for  freedom of expression and the voicing of a collective will, that which has been seen across the world in the sheer volume of  messages asking ‘Where is Santiago Maldonado?’.

If that is a phenomenon that merits punishment and silencing, then society will  ave truly lost its voice and its conscience.


* On Twitter: @danedwardsgoal

Dan Edwards

Poll

Op-Ed

Top Stories

  1. 1Moyano denies graft claims as he leads massive protest in Buenos AiresMoyano denies graft claims as he leads massive protest in Buenos Aires
  2. 2Ricardo Darín, Les Luthiers join effort to help protect the Antarctic Ocean
  3. 3Making Argentina safe for corruption
  4. 4Thousands demand abortion law reform in protest before National Congress
  5. 5Low-cost airlines ready for take-off in 2018
  6. 6AFA announces 28 percent price hike on Superliga tickets
  7. 7Moyano: 'Any violence at march is gov't provocation'
  8. 8Glyphosate use on the rise in Argentina, despite controversy
  9. 9Legal pressure builds on Moyano as protest march date draws closer
  10. 10Amateur Argentine astronomer captures birth of a supernova