Buenos Aires Times

latin america D-day for former president

Brazil's top court set to decide fate of ex-president Lula

Brazil's top court is set to rule on whether former president Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva should start a 12-year prison sentence for corruption, potentially upending this year's presidential election.

Wednesday 4 April, 2018
Brazil's former president Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva speaks during his presidential campaign rally with members of his Workers’ Party (PT) and leaders of other parties in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil.
Brazil's former president Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva speaks during his presidential campaign rally with members of his Workers’ Party (PT) and leaders of other parties in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. Foto:AP-Leo Correa

Related News

Brazil's top court could rule as soon as today whether former president Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva can stay out of prison while appealing a corruption conviction, a decision that could radically alter October's presidential election in Latin America's largest nation.

Lula, who was once wildly popular after his two terms as president in 2003-2010, was convicted last year of helping a construction company get sweetheart contracts in exchange for the promise of a beachfront apartment. The conviction was handed down by Judge Sergio Moro, who is presiding over cases involving the largest corruption scandal in Brazil's history, known as Lava Jato ("Car Wash"). Moro is hailed as a hero by many while detractors consider him a partisan hit man.

Lula has always maintained his innocence, saying this case as well as several other corruption charges that have yet to be tried are attempts to keep him off the presidential ballot. Despite the legal troubles that have angered some Brazilians, Lula leads preference polls to return to office.

However, Lula's denials received a blow in January, when an appeals court upheld the conviction involving the beachfront apartment. The three reviewing magistrates even lengthened the sentence to 12 years and one month.

While Lula has further appeals available, he could be forced under Brazilian law to begin serving his sentence, which Moro and the other judges have ordered.

At this point, da Silva's last and best hope of staying out of jail — and keeping his re-election hopes alive — is the Supreme Federal Tribunal, which scheduled a Wednesday hearing on his habeas corpus petition.

Lula's lawyers argue their client has a constitutional right to stay out of jail until all appeals are exhausted.

In an unrelated case in 2016, the Supreme Federal Tribunal disagreed with that logic, ruling that a convict could start serving a sentence after a first appeal was denied.

How the 11 justices will rule this time is anybody's guess, as the case involves a former president who continues to have a wide following in a deeply polarised nation. Throughout all the legal battles, Lula has been campaigning nationwide, criticizing detractors and promising not to give up. Last week, while campaigning in the southern state of Paraná, where Moro convicted him, two buses in his caravan where hit with bullets. Nobody was hurt.

Chief Justice Carmen Lucia initially did not respond to Lula's petition. But a few weeks ago she changed course amid intense pressure, calling a court session that was then postponed until after the Easter holiday.

With emotions running high, earlier this week Lucia urged Brazilians to calmly accept whatever was decided.

"We live in times of intolerance and intransigence against people and institutions," she said. "For this very reason, this is a time when one must ask for serenity. Serenity so that ideological differences are not a source of social disorder."

- TIMES/AP

Poll

Op-Ed

Top Stories

  1. 1TV 'sweetheart' Juan Darthés accused of assaulting 16-year-old costarTV 'sweetheart' Juan Darthés accused of assaulting 16-year-old costar
  2. 2#MiraComoNosPonemos: Argentines speak out against sexual abuse
  3. 3Prosecutors request arrest of Techint CEO Paolo Rocca
  4. 4'Japan wants to support Macri's presidency'
  5. 5Shaken by corruption, Peruvians back major gov't overhaul
  6. 6Techint’ Rocca denies bribery claims before judge
  7. 7President Macri's father and brother to face court investigation into alleged graft
  8. 8Off the rails: how corruption and rising costs stalled the Sarmiento rail project
  9. 9Former VP Boudou leaves prison, claims 'Argentina has political prisoners'
  10. 10Argentina, China sign more than 30 agriculture and investment deals